Library HoTT.Categories.Category.Sigma.Univalent

Lifting saturation from categories to sigma/subcategories

Require Import Category.Core Category.Morphisms.
Require Import Category.Univalent.
Require Import Category.Sigma.Core Category.Sigma.OnObjects Category.Sigma.OnMorphisms.
Require Import HoTT.Types HoTT.Basics.

Set Implicit Arguments.
Generalizable All Variables.

Local Notation pr1_type := Overture.pr1 (only parsing).

Local Open Scope path_scope.
Local Open Scope morphism_scope.

Local Open Scope function_scope.

TODO: Following a comment from Mike Shulman (https://github.com/HoTT/HoTT/pull/670#issuecomment-68907833), much of this can probably be subsumed by a general theorem proving that univalence lifts along suitable pseudomonic functors (http://ncatlab.org/nlab/show/pseudomonic+functor).

Lift saturation to sigma on objects whenever the property is an hProp

Section onobjects.
  Variable A : PreCategory.
  Variable Pobj : A Type.

  #[export] Instance iscategory_sig_obj `{ a, IsHProp (Pobj a), A_cat : IsCategory A}
  : IsCategory (sig_obj A Pobj).
  Proof.
    intros s d.
    (* This makes typeclass search go faster. *)
    pose @isequiv_compose.
    refine (isequiv_homotopic
              ((issig_full_isomorphic (sig_obj A Pobj) _ _ o (issig_full_isomorphic A _ _)^-1)
                 o (@idtoiso A s.1 d.1)
                 o pr1_path)
              _).
    intro x; destruct x.
    reflexivity.
  Defined.

The converse is not true; consider Pobj := fun _ Empty.
End onobjects.

Lift saturation to sigma on objects whenever the property is automatically and uniquely true of isomorphisms

Section onmorphisms.
  Variable A : PreCategory.
  Variable Pmor : s d, morphism A s d Type.

  Local Notation mor s d := { m : _ | Pmor s d m }.
  Context `(HPmor : s d, IsHSet (mor s d)).

  Variable Pidentity : x, @Pmor x x (@identity A _).
  Variable Pcompose : s d d' m1 m2,
                        @Pmor d d' m1
                         @Pmor s d m2
                         @Pmor s d' (m1 o m2).

  Local Notation identity x := (@identity A x; @Pidentity x).
  Local Notation compose m1 m2 := (m1.1 o m2.1; @Pcompose _ _ _ m1.1 m2.1 m1.2 m2.2)%morphism.

  Hypothesis P_associativity
  : x1 x2 x3 x4 (m1 : mor x1 x2) (m2 : mor x2 x3) (m3 : mor x3 x4),
      compose (compose m3 m2) m1 = compose m3 (compose m2 m1).

  Hypothesis P_left_identity
  : a b (f : mor a b),
      compose (identity b) f = f.

  Hypothesis P_right_identity
  : a b (f : mor a b),
      compose f (identity a) = f.

  Local Notation A' := (@sig_mor' A Pmor HPmor Pidentity Pcompose P_associativity P_left_identity P_right_identity).

To have any hope of relating IsCategory A with IsCategory A', we assume that Pmor is automatically and uniquely true on isomorphisms.
  Context `{ s d m, IsIsomorphism m Contr (Pmor s d m)}.

  Definition iscategory_sig_mor_helper {s d}
  : @Isomorphic A' s d @Isomorphic A s d.
  Proof.
    refine ((issig_full_isomorphic A _ _) o _ o (issig_full_isomorphic A' _ _)^-1).
    exact (functor_sigma
             pr1_type
             (fun _
                functor_sigma
                  pr1_type
                  (fun _
                     functor_sigma
                       pr1_path
                       (fun _pr1_path)))).
  Defined.

  Local Instance isequiv_iscategory_sig_mor_helper s d
  : IsEquiv (@iscategory_sig_mor_helper s d).
  Proof.
    simple refine (isequiv_adjointify _ _ _ _).
    { intro e.
       (e : morphism _ _ _; center _).
       (e^-1%morphism; center _);
        simple refine (path_sigma _ _ _ _ _);
        first [ apply left_inverse
              | apply right_inverse
              | by apply path_ishprop ]. }
    { intro; by apply path_isomorphic. }
    { intros x; apply path_isomorphic.
      exact (path_sigma' _ 1 (contr _)). }
  Defined.

  #[export] Instance iscategory_sig_mor `{A_cat : IsCategory A}
  : IsCategory A'.
  Proof.
    intros s d.
    (* Use equiv_compose rather than "o" to speed up typeclass search. *)
    refine (isequiv_homotopic
              (equiv_compose iscategory_sig_mor_helper^-1 (@idtoiso _ _ _))
              _).
    intro x; apply path_isomorphic; cbn.
    destruct x; exact (path_sigma' _ 1 (contr _)).
  Defined.

  Definition iscategory_from_sig_mor `{A'_cat : IsCategory A'}
  : IsCategory A.
  Proof.
    intros s d.
    refine (isequiv_homotopic
              (iscategory_sig_mor_helper
                 o (@idtoiso A' _ _))
              _).
    intro x; apply path_isomorphic; cbn.
    destruct x; reflexivity.
  Defined.

  #[export] Instance isequiv_iscategory_sig_mor `{Funext}
  : IsEquiv (@iscategory_sig_mor).
  Proof.
    exact (isequiv_iff_hprop _ (@iscategory_from_sig_mor)).
  Defined.
End onmorphisms.

Lift saturation to sigma on both objects and morphisms

Section on_both.
  Variable A : PreCategory.
  Variable Pobj : A Type.

  Local Notation obj := { x : _ | Pobj x } (only parsing).

  Variable Pmor : s d : obj, morphism A s.1 d.1 Type.

  Local Notation mor s d := { m : _ | Pmor s d m } (only parsing).
  Context `(HPmor : s d, IsHSet (mor s d)).

  Variable Pidentity : x, @Pmor x x (@identity A _).
  Variable Pcompose : s d d' m1 m2,
                        @Pmor d d' m1
                         @Pmor s d m2
                         @Pmor s d' (m1 o m2).

  Local Notation identity x := (@identity A x.1; @Pidentity x).
  Local Notation compose m1 m2 := (m1.1 o m2.1; @Pcompose _ _ _ m1.1 m2.1 m1.2 m2.2)%morphism.

  Hypothesis P_associativity
  : x1 x2 x3 x4 (m1 : mor x1 x2) (m2 : mor x2 x3) (m3 : mor x3 x4),
      compose (compose m3 m2) m1 = compose m3 (compose m2 m1).

  Hypothesis P_left_identity
  : a b (f : mor a b),
      compose (identity b) f = f.

  Hypothesis P_right_identity
  : a b (f : mor a b),
      compose f (identity a) = f.

  Local Notation A' := (@sig' A Pobj Pmor HPmor Pidentity Pcompose P_associativity P_left_identity P_right_identity).

We must assume some relation on the properties; we assume that the path space of the extra data on objects is classified by isomorphisms of the extra data on objects.
  Local Definition Pmor_iso_T s d m m' left right :=
    ({ e : Pmor s d m
     | { e' : Pmor d s m'
       | { _ : transport (Pmor _ _) ((left : m' o m = 1)%morphism) (Pcompose e' e) = Pidentity _
         | transport (Pmor _ _) ((right : m o m' = 1)%morphism) (Pcompose e e') = Pidentity _ } } }).

  Global Arguments Pmor_iso_T / .

  Local Definition Pmor_iso_T' x (xp xp' : Pobj x)
    := { e : Pmor (x; xp) (x; xp') 1
       | { e' : Pmor (x; xp') (x; xp) 1
         | { _ : Pcompose e' e = Pcompose (Pidentity _) (Pidentity _)
           | Pcompose e e' = Pcompose (Pidentity _) (Pidentity _) } } }.

  Global Arguments Pmor_iso_T' / .

  Local Definition Pidtoiso x (xp xp' : Pobj x) (H : xp = xp')
  : Pmor_iso_T' xp xp'.
  Proof.
    destruct H.
     (Pidentity _).
     (Pidentity _).
    split; reflexivity.
  Defined.

  Global Arguments Pidtoiso / .

TODO: generalize this to a theorem A P, IsHSet A IsHSet { x : A | P x } x, IsHSet (P x), inO_unsigma of #672
  Local Instance ishset_pmor {s d m} : IsHSet (Pmor s d m).
  Proof.
    apply istrunc_S.
    intros p q.
    apply hprop_allpath.
    let H := constr:(_ : x y : mor s d, IsHProp (x = y)) in
    pose proof (@path_ishprop _ (H (m; p) (m; q))) as H'.
    intros x y.
    specialize (H' (path_sigma' _ 1 x) (path_sigma' _ 1 y)).
    unfold path_sigma', path_sigma in H'.
    apply (ap (path_sigma_uncurried (Pmor s d) (m; p) (m; q)))^-1 in H'.
    assert (H'' : H'..1 = idpath) by apply path_ishprop.
    exact (transport (fun H'1transport _ H'1 _ = _) H'' H'..2).
  Defined.

  Local Definition Pmor_iso_adjust x xp xp'
  : (Pmor_iso_T (x; xp) (x; xp') 1 1 (left_identity _ _ _ _) (right_identity _ _ _ _))
      <~> Pmor_iso_T' xp xp'.
  Proof.
    refine (equiv_functor_sigma_id _); intro.
    refine (equiv_functor_sigma_id _); intro.
    refine (equiv_functor_sigma' (equiv_iff_hprop _ _) (fun _equiv_iff_hprop _ _));
      cbn; intro H';
      first [ apply moveL_transport_V in H'
                | apply moveR_transport_p ];
      refine (H' @ _);
      first [ refine (_ @ ((P_left_identity (identity (x; _)))^)..2)
                | refine ((((P_left_identity (identity (x; _)))^)..2)^ @ _) ];
      exact (ap (fun ptransport _ p _) (path_ishprop _ _)).
  Defined.

  Global Arguments Pmor_iso_adjust / .

  Local Definition iso_A'_code {s d}
  : (@Isomorphic A' s d)
     { e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
       | Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e) right_inverse }.
  Proof.
    intro e.
    simple refine (_; _).
    { (e : morphism _ _ _).1.
       (e^-1%morphism).1.
      - exact (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e)..1.
      - exact (@right_inverse _ _ _ e e)..1. }
    { (e : morphism _ _ _).2.
       (e^-1%morphism).2; cbn.
       (((@left_inverse _ _ _ e e))..2).
      exact (@right_inverse _ _ _ e e)..2. }
  Defined.

  Local Definition iso_A'_decode_helper {s d}
        (e : { e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
             | Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e) right_inverse })
  : @IsIsomorphism A' _ _ (e.1:morphism A s.1 d.1; (e.2).1).
  Proof.
    eexists. Unshelve.
    3:exact (e.1^-1%morphism; e.2.2.1).
    { exact (path_sigma' _ left_inverse e.2.2.2.1). }
    { exact (path_sigma' _ right_inverse e.2.2.2.2). }
  Defined.

  Local Definition iso_A'_decode {s d}
  : { e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
    | Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e) right_inverse }
     (@Isomorphic A' s d).
  Proof.
    intro e.
    eexists. Unshelve.
    2:exact (e.1 : morphism _ _ _; e.2.1).
    apply iso_A'_decode_helper.
  Defined.

  Local Definition equiv_iso_A'_eisretr_helper {s d}
        (x : {e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
             | Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e) right_inverse })
  : transport
      (fun e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
         Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 left_inverse right_inverse)
      (path_isomorphic (iso_A'_code (iso_A'_decode x)).1 x.1 1)
      (iso_A'_code (iso_A'_decode x)).2 = x.2.
  Proof.
    simple refine (path_sigma _ _ _ _ _); cycle 1.
    (* Speed up typeclass search: *)
    1:pose @istrunc_sigma; pose @istrunc_paths;
      simple refine (path_sigma _ _ _ _ (path_ishprop _ _)).
    all:repeat match goal with
                 | [ |- (transport ?P ?p ?z).1 = _ ] ⇒ rewrite (@ap_transport _ P _ _ _ p (fun _ xx.1))
                 | [ |- (transport ?P ?p ?z).2.1 = _ ] ⇒ rewrite (@ap_transport _ P _ _ _ p (fun _ xx.2.1))
                 | [ |- transport (fun _ ⇒ ?x) _ _ = _ ] ⇒ rewrite transport_const
                 | [ |- transport (fun x ⇒ ?f (@morphism_inverse _ _ _ (@morphism_isomorphic _ _ _ x) _)) _ _ = _ ]
                   ⇒ rewrite (@transport_compose _ _ _ _ f (fun x ⇒ (@morphism_inverse _ _ _ (@morphism_isomorphic _ _ _ x) (@isisomorphism_isomorphic _ _ _ x))))
                 | [ |- transport (?f o ?g) _ _ = _ ] ⇒ rewrite (@transport_compose _ _ _ _ f g)
                 | [ |- transport (fun x ⇒ ?f (?g x)) _ _ = _ ] ⇒ rewrite (@transport_compose _ _ _ _ f g)
                 | [ |- context[ap (@morphism_isomorphic ?a ?b ?c) (path_isomorphic ?i ?j ?x)] ]
                   ⇒ change (ap (@morphism_isomorphic a b c)) with ((path_isomorphic i j)^-1%function);
                     rewrite (@eissect _ _ (path_isomorphic i j) _ x)
                 | [ |- context[ap (fun e : Isomorphic _ _ ⇒ @morphism_inverse ?C ?s ?d _ _) (path_isomorphic ?i ?j ?x)] ]
                   ⇒ rewrite (@ap_morphism_inverse_path_isomorphic C s d i j x 1)
                 | [ |- transport ?P 1 ?x = ?y ] ⇒ change (x = y)
                 | [ |- (((iso_A'_code (iso_A'_decode ?x)).2).2).1 = ((?x.2).2).1 ] ⇒ reflexivity
                 | [ |- (((iso_A'_code (iso_A'_decode ?x)).2).1) = ((?x.2).1) ] ⇒ reflexivity
               end.
  Qed.

  Local Definition equiv_iso_A' {s d}
  : (@Isomorphic A' s d)
      <~> { e : @Isomorphic A s.1 d.1
          | Pmor_iso_T s d e e^-1 (@left_inverse _ _ _ e e) right_inverse }.
  Proof.
    refine (equiv_adjointify iso_A'_code iso_A'_decode _ _).
    { intro.
      simple refine (path_sigma _ _ _ _ _).
      { apply path_isomorphic; reflexivity. }
      { apply equiv_iso_A'_eisretr_helper. } }
    { intro.
      apply path_isomorphic.
      reflexivity. }
  Defined.

  Context `{Pisotoid : x xp xp', IsEquiv (@Pidtoiso x xp xp')}.

  Local Arguments Pmor_iso_T : simpl never.

  #[export] Instance iscategory_sig `{A_cat : IsCategory A}
  : IsCategory A'.
  Proof.
    intros s d.
    snrefine (isequiv_homotopic
              ((equiv_iso_A'^-1)
                 o (functor_sigma _ _)
                 o (path_sigma_uncurried _ _ _)^-1)
              _); [exact _ | | | exact _ | |].
    (* try exact _ leaves the third remaining goal unchanged, but takes ~9s to do so. *)
    { exact (@idtoiso A _ _). }
    { destruct s as [s0 s1], d as [d0 d1]; cbn.
      intro p; destruct p; cbn.
      refine ((@Pmor_iso_adjust s0 s1 d1)^-1 o _).
      exact (@Pidtoiso _ _ _). }
    { (* Do this in small steps to make it fast. *)
      napply isequiv_compose. 1:apply isequiv_inverse.
      napply isequiv_compose. 2:apply isequiv_inverse.
      nrefine isequiv_functor_sigma. 1:apply A_cat.
      destruct s, d.
      simpl Overture.pr1.
      intro p; destruct p.
      eapply isequiv_compose.
      - exact _.
      - eapply @isequiv_inverse. }
    { intro p; apply path_isomorphic; destruct p.
      reflexivity. }
  Defined.
End on_both.